The Lake House Tavern Prime Rib Challenge in Windham: My Night With a 64-Ounce Steak
By Sebago Lake Lovin
I'm a huge, huge prime rib fan. So when I heard Lake House Tavern in Windham had a 64-ounce, four-pound Prime Rib Challenge, I had to see what it was all about. I grabbed some of my friends, we headed on down for the night, and we decided to make a go of it.
Lake House Tavern has been around a couple of years in the Sebago Lakes region, serving all types of great food. The Prime Rib Challenge, though, is brand new over the last month. That was all I needed to hear.
A table in the back, and a list of rules
We headed in, grabbed a table in the back, and ordered. Our waitress, Lindsey, walked me through the rules and held up the flyer so there was no confusion about what I was getting myself into.
The official Prime Rib Challenge flyer at Lake House Tavern. — Photo: Sebago Lake Lovin
Here's what that flyer says, and what she made sure I understood.
The challenge is on Thursday nights, starting at 5 p.m. You have one hour to finish the entire dinner by yourself, and you've got to completely clear the plate. That dinner is a massive 64-ounce prime rib (that's four pounds), a large baked potato, a vegetable, a dinner roll, and skinny rings. If you finish it, you get a Lake House Tavern challenge T-shirt, and the meal is free. If you don't, the meal is $95. And if you eat too much and throw up, there's a $100 cleaning fee on top of that.
Oh, and one more thing she made a point of: you have to eat everything on the plate, including the fat.
That one got me. Yeah, that's right, you've got to eat the fat too. It immediately reminded me of that old John Candy movie, The Great Outdoors, when he sat down with that giant steak. I had a little problem with that rule. Four pounds of prime rib is already a lot of steak, and then they want the fat too.
John Candy in The Great Outdoors (1988).
Before the plate even hit the table, Brian, Lake House Tavern's head chef, came out to welcome us. He's the one who prepared this tremendous prime rib, and you could tell he was proud of it.
Brian, Lake House Tavern's head chef, came out to welcome us. — Photo: Sebago Lake Lovin
The 64-ounce, four-pound prime rib. — Photo: Sebago Lake Lovin
The plate arrives. — Photo: Sebago Lake Lovin
I went in hungry. It didn't matter.
I went into the day ready, or at least I thought I was. I didn't eat anything all day. I tried to limit my liquid so I didn't fill up my stomach, and I didn't eat any bread prior to the meal.
But that didn't matter. I was not going to finish this. I didn't get even halfway through, and that was it for me. I didn't continue.
I didn't get even halfway through. — Photo: Sebago Lake Lovin
So the prime rib beat me. No T-shirt, no free meal, and no shame in it, either. If you saw the video we posted, you already know the look on my face when that plate came out.
But there's a happy ending. We worked together with Lake House Tavern, and instead of paying for the meal, the cost of the prime rib was donated to Camp Sunshine, so everybody wins. I also went home with what amounted to two king-size-plus prime ribs, and I ate one of them later on that night with some friends. It's a whole heck of a lot of steak.
If you want to try it out, it's on Thursday nights, it's $95, and if you finish it, you get it for free. Come hungry. Come with friends. And maybe don't count on willpower and an empty stomach to get you there, because I tried that, and the prime rib still won.
About Lake House Tavern
Lake House Tavern is at 907 Roosevelt Trail in Windham, Maine, in the Sebago Lakes region. They serve all types of great food, not just this challenge.
Dining room hours are Monday through Saturday, 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., and Sunday, 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. The Prime Rib Challenge itself is Thursdays starting at 5 p.m. You can reach them at (207) 894-3020, or visit lakehousewindham.com. They're also on Facebook.
Come on down Thursday night
The full 64-ounce Prime Rib Challenge video is coming. Follow @sebagolakelovin so you don't miss it, and if you're in the Sebago Lakes region on a Thursday, come on down to Lake House Tavern and see if you can finish what I couldn't.
And if you're looking for a pair of floating sunglasses built for the lake, you can find them at lakelovin.com.